US Judge Acquits MIT-Educated Brothers in $25 Million Cryptocurrency Heist Case

Facebook
X
Email

A US federal judge has acquitted two brothers educated at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) who were accused of stealing $25 million in cryptocurrency through a transaction strategy that prosecutors said exploited a software vulnerability on the Ethereum network.

US District Judge Jessica Clarke issued the ruling in Manhattan on Monday, November 16, 2026, concluding that prosecutors had failed to establish the essential elements of wire fraud and related charges against Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno.

The decision follows a jury deadlock in November 2025, when jurors were unable to reach a unanimous verdict on whether the brothers were guilty of the alleged cryptocurrency scheme.

The brothers’ legal teams welcomed the ruling. Daniel Marx, who represented Anton Peraire-Bueno at Fick & Marx, said the decision demonstrated that his client and his brother had not misrepresented their trading activities. He also criticized the prosecution, arguing that it reflected a fundamental misunderstanding of decentralized financial systems, including Ethereum.

Katherine Trefz, an attorney representing James Peraire-Bueno at Williams & Connolly, described the judgment as the just and correct outcome. The US Attorney’s Office responsible for prosecuting the case declined to comment.

How the Alleged $25 Million Cryptocurrency Scheme Worked

Federal prosecutors initially indicted the brothers in May 2024, alleging that they had spent several months developing a strategy to manipulate transaction-validation processes on the Ethereum blockchain.

According to the prosecution, the brothers exploited a vulnerability in MEV-Boost, software widely used by Ethereum network validators. These validators play a critical role in verifying transactions before they are recorded on the blockchain.

Prosecutors alleged that, in April 2023, the brothers carried out a carefully planned operation lasting just 12 seconds. The strategy allegedly involved creating a bait-and-switch trap that attracted automated cryptocurrency trading bots before diverting approximately $25 million from other traders.

The government argued that the operation represented an unprecedented form of financial fraud involving the manipulation of decentralized blockchain infrastructure.

However, the defense maintained that the brothers had used a legitimate trading strategy rather than committing fraud. Their lawyers argued that exploiting an opportunity within an open blockchain system did not automatically constitute criminal conduct.

Judge Says Prosecutors Failed to Establish Fraud

In her ruling, Judge Clarke agreed that the prosecution had not presented sufficient evidence to demonstrate that the brothers made material misrepresentations during the transactions.

She emphasized that the alleged transactions did not involve false statements and were not conducted on a regulated market with rules specifically prohibiting the disputed activity.

The judge clarified that the court’s responsibility was not to determine whether the brothers’ actions were ethical or morally acceptable, or whether their conduct might have violated other laws. Instead, the central issue was whether the evidence presented at trial could support convictions for wire fraud and related offenses.

The ruling ultimately concluded that prosecutors had not met that legal standard.

MIT Background Put Brothers’ Technical Skills in Focus

The brothers’ academic backgrounds also attracted attention during the proceedings. Both graduated from MIT, where prosecutors argued they developed the technical expertise used in their alleged trading operation.

Anton Peraire-Bueno earned a bachelor’s degree in computer science and engineering in 2023. His brother James completed a bachelor’s degree in mathematics and aeronautics in 2019, followed by a master’s degree in aeronautics in 2021.

The case highlighted growing legal questions surrounding decentralized finance, automated trading systems and the responsibilities of participants operating within blockchain networks.

The acquittal represents a significant development in one of the most unusual cryptocurrency fraud prosecutions brought by US federal authorities, particularly as regulators and courts continue to address how existing financial laws apply to emerging digital asset technologies.

Never miss any important news. Subscribe to our newsletter.

Latest News

Scroll to Top